点滴记忆Drip memory

使用Lanxin搭建的站点

这段话说得有道理吗?Does this passage make sense

2019-11-21 zsxxz

最近看到在社交媒体上发了这么一段话:
假使所有的指挥官在他认为他的处境已经毫无希望时马上投降,那么就不会有人赢得战争。甚至于,在绝对无希望的环境中,也常常可能是死里求活的。”

这话说得有道理。绝境求生是本能,不抛弃不放弃就有机会嘛,真理。那再一看这话是谁说的呢?一看署名,坏了,曼施坦因,二战时候的德国元帅,入侵法国和苏联他都有份。

坏蛋说的,这话的意思就变了,这就是一个坏蛋到了黄河还心不死,要负隅顽抗嘛,谬论。
再一想,也不对,曼施坦因后来因为和希特勒意见不合被撤职了,后来还得以善终。
作为一个有成就的军事思想家,是不是说的话也有点道理呢?

所以你看,如果我们不知道自己到底要什么,学习啥,向谁学习,都会学成一笔糊涂账。
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I recently saw this on social media:
"If all the commanders surrender immediately when he thinks his situation is hopeless, then no one will win the war. Even in an absolutely hopeless environment, it is often possible to survive in the dead."

This makes sense. Survival is an instinct. If you don't give up, you have a chance, truth. Who said this again? A look at the signature, broken, Manstein, the German Marshal of World War II, invaded France and the Soviet Union.

The bad guy said, the meaning of this words has changed, this is a bad guy to the Yellow River, still not dying, to be recalcitrant, public opinion.
Thinking again, it was not right. Manstein was later dismissed because of his disagreement with Hitler, and later he was able to end his life. As an accomplished military thinker, is it a bit reasonable to say something?

So you see, if we don't know what we want, learn, and learn from them, we will learn a foolish account.

标签: 这段话 说得 有道理 指挥官

评论排行榜

    评论:

    喵萌
    2019-11-21 15:54
    有一种无知,叫“什么都懂”;
    有一种茫然,叫“什么都信”;
    有一种徒劳,叫“什么都会”。
    馨香
    2019-11-21 15:52
    想起了一篇文章:
    我做狂人,但不做人渣。写的刚好也是一个二战德国舰船及它的指挥官的故事。文章里有这么一句:
    “有一条网民的评论,不妨记在这里:“朗斯多夫挽救了所有船员的性命。不过大家可否想过,如果我们在‘斯佩伯爵号’上服役,你是否会一辈子都感谢这个男人?”这两段故事可以都来读一读,你心中会有自己的答案。
    当我们认为曼施坦因是侵略头目时,他的话意味着负隅抵抗,当我们认为他是一个识识务者的俊杰时,他的话就是一个军事经验的分享。同样一句话,身份变了,含义也不同,所以对标学习,目标明确,方得始终。
    遥远
    2019-11-21 15:50
    听人说话要听内容,不要根据说话的人来判断说话的对错。但这的确是常见误区,一个牛人说出来离经叛道的话,大家就会觉得牛人就是语出惊人,与众不同,而我说的话,大家只会各种反驳和抨击。
    取其精华,去其糟粕,太难啦,所以要向对的人学习。但也要具备知识鉴赏力,懂得判断什么是好知识

    发表评论: